Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream - Indianapolis, Indiana

Isabel O.

Los mejores helados que e probado y el personal super amable

Joaquin D.

Excelente servicio y muy ricos

x P.

My husband and I visited for a late night snack and we loved this little cute place. The girls gave us samples since there were so many good choices to pick from. I went with the lemon custard. The staff were super sweet and the ice cream was a 11/10. Will be coming back before we leave town.

Micah G.

This is a small place but pretty good ice cream. Great place to go on a date. It’s a little loud sometimes but it reminds me of a little old soda shop.

Kelly F.

Omg this is some of the best homemade ice cream in the state of Indiana. If you’re in the area you need to go here with your friends, family, and co workers . You will not be disappointed. The speciality sundaes are enough for two people . The ice cream is so creamy and fresh, with lots of flavors to choose from. I had a hard time deciding so I was able to do a scoop of each. The staff were young , but they were friendly and provide good service. We will definitely be back when we’re in the area.

Adam H.

Excellent ice cream!!!!
Very rich and creamy. My wife got a
reese's peanut butter cup sundae, and I got a Turkish coffee milkshake.
They had many flavors, and it was difficult to choose. All sounded amazing. Very quick and polite staff. Definitely will be back again

Niegetta H.

Easter weekend and the weather was great! Decided to try this place out after living on this side of town over a year. Wonderful experience, instantly greeted with a smile. Simple decor and easy to read menu. And the store was organized. Told lady first time in, and she, in a timely manner, told us what our choices were and what they offered. Not even 5 mins of us walking in people were coming in quick, so another young lady helped us out. She was just as sweet. Fair pricing and worth the money! Ice cream is homemade and rich. Super yummy. Family of five, and we all enjoyed our ice cream right outside the business. That was a really cool feature. Two nice size sturdy benches. Will be back again 🙂

Quintin C.

The ice cream at Sundae's is one word - addicting. The exterior and interior of the store are nothing special - standard run of the mill storefront. The staff are all very friendly and helpful - all younger and haven't been jaded by life (are jokes allowed in this review?).

Now, the ice cream. Creamy while frozen and runny when it hits hot air - tells me a couple things:

1. It's not overloaded with stabilizers
2. Plenty of cream in the ice cream - part of what makes it delicious

The flavors have been fantastic. Pictured are the banana cream pie and the raspberry limoncello cake...and they both taste what they say they're supposed to without being a sugar bomb. And they have pie crust (salty graham cracker) and cake in the ice cream.

Not pictured are the pistachio and key lime pie. Again, flavors are on point - especially that key lime pie, I love it when citric acid hits my tongue and causes my mouth to salivate. The pistachio was loaded with pistachios - can't be cheap.

The prices are definitely affordable/reasonable and the scoops are generous. At the time of this review, this is my benchmark for Indy.