Quincys Steak & Spirits - Leadville, Colorado

Adri O.

We had an amazing experience at this restaurant. The steak was simply delicious, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. The service was top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff at all times. The desserts were the perfect ending—irresistible and full of flavor. At first, we were skeptical because the menu is limited, as they offer daily specials, but every dish exceeded our expectations. The atmosphere is also very traditional, adding to the charm and authenticity of the experience. Highly recommended!

Diane K.

I have been going to Quincys for 25 years and have enjoyed the prime rib. Sadly the quality of the meat has gone down to the point where you can’t even cut it or chew it. I had to spit out the meat into a napkin because I couldn’t swallow it. My problem is the product should never have been served. It was full of grissle. The manager did not handle our complaint well. My point was to the manager is, why serve a piece of meat uneddible in the first place. Go back to your higher standards Quincys. We will not come back.

Jacob S.

What a great restaurant! Was very happy with everything about it. Me and my wife both got the steak. It was cooked exactly as we asked and had so much juice and flavor. The service was great and happy to tell us about the history of the building. Great experience! Come and try for a great experience in historic Leadville.

Ely G. J.

Great place for prime rib! Very simple menu, wait staff was quick and efficient. No frills, just the way I like it!

Mr.E

Edit:
This was our first time back after 2 years, and the food was just as great as I remember. The steak was cooked properly, the potato was soft and buttery, and the bread was a perfect palet cleanser. The steak sauce had an interesting aftertaste, but that's perhaps only a personal preference. The Shirley Temple was an excellent drink choice, and the staff were most kind. We were seated quickly, however, the waitress seemed unacquainted with the drink menu...nevertheless kind and helpful. After the meal, I excused myself to the washroom to relieve myself whenever I found that the door was locked! The restaurant only appeared to include a single sized person washroom accommodation. Sadly, I never saw this person leave the washroom...I had to relieve myself elsewhere. They could still be there? Shortly after this, and well without warning, we were surprised to find an automatic gratuity for our party of five...
Apart from all this, I would still recommend trying out this steak & spirits for your spiriting needs.

Previous Review (inexperienced):
Amazing steak, baked potatoes, and bread!!! Was seated right away, given water and got food quickly. Nice restrooms and fun hotel feel to the restaurant. Tasted really good after climbing Mt. Elbert!!

Wendy F.

The staff who seated us was so friendly. The restaurant atmosphere has a wonderfully old steakhouse feel that I found so comfortable. The service was attentive and quick. Now to the most important part. I ordered a 6oz filet that was perfectly seasoned and perfectly cooked. I have paid so much more for steaks that were nowhere near as good. I would visit here again and again if I could! I highly recommend that if you’re coming for a train ride-plan for dinner at Quincy’s!!!

Amy W.

Do not eat here. One star for food is too generous. With a limited selection menu (filet mignon or vegetable lasagna the night we were there), you would think they knew how to present those dishes. We both had the filet - thinking the prices were a steal when we ordered, yet the smell and appearance of the steaks when they arrived told us we were wrong, very wrong. Cooked medium rare as requested, they steaks were an odd texture to chew. They came bacon wrapped yet neither the steak nor the bacon had a flavor beyond rancid oil. Baked potatoes were almost fully cooked and the "butter" on the potato was as flavorless as the meat. Even the bread, though pillowy, was off with a slight bitter taste. The dinner salad was fine though drowning in the ok house dressing. Our server was very nice and did a fine job. The atmosphere reminded you that you were in an
Old small Colorado town post boom (and not in a good way). We were astounding to see locals dining as well as having left positive reviews. People of Leadville: Quincy's does not make a good steak! Head to Buena Vista next time you eat. Locals told us the Grill was good - we chose Quincy's since we didn't want a burger or Mexican. We will forever regret that decision.previous poor reviews were responded to by the owner - short of fully comping our meal and erasing our memories of it nothing would have made this right.

Hank D.

Quincy's is a great place to dine. We have been coming here for over 15 years. Friday and Saturday they have Prime Rib, which is great. This time we were there on Tuesday and I had the 15 oz fillet, medium. It was perfect. Service was good and we had an enjoyable evening.