Cornwall Sweets - Cornwall, New York

M M.

Update: I can’t respond to the owner so I have to place an update. I have included a picture description of what is says on the website for the brownie which is why I expected it warm but further than that the brownie was almost non existent… it was ice cream w brownie crumbs… as for the cupcake I did not receive a call/text/ or even voicemail regarding it and we don’t like filling so it was not eaten… a plain vanilla cupcake is all we wanted and that’s what was shown on the website. Thanks for responding though… just giving an honest review and will update if we try again.

Ordered a plain vanilla cupcake with vanilla frosting got a vanilla cupcake with filling and it looks nothing like the picture and has crumbs and weird cream that’s looks like a spider web on top… also ordered a brownie Sundae and I got pretty much a bunch of ice cream with brownie bits a cherry and hot fudge….it was supposed to be a warm brownie with ice cream on it …. I got ice cream with a few brownie bits Here are the pics … just wish I got what I ordered…

Bianka K. S.

Stopped by late on a Friday night when nothing else seemed to be open. Sure, I went because it was open til 9:30 but this place ended up being soooo much better than just a random sweet fix! Their salted caramel cake and Boston Cream bomb are so so good! The cake especially, it was exceptional. The girl behind the counter was also super nice and helpful. Best dessert spot in the area!

Chris B.

A quaint little sweet-shop nestled on Main Street USA. Great atmosphere, great service, and outstanding treats! We ordered a vanilla shake for our son, and we had two scoops of Peanut Butter Crunch.

Anthony A.

Wonderful small business.
The convenience and wonderful selection of this shop should make it a GO-TO if you need ANY type of sweet treat.

The location is convenient with plenty of street side parking and the hours are crazy convenient.
Open late (until 9:30pm at this time) which was a godsend and perfect save as a last minute Valentine’s Day gift for my wife.

But the selection of homemade and quality baked goods is what impressed me the most. For such a small shop - They truly have everything!

Chocolate dipped pretzels, candys, ice cream, designer level cupcakes, pie, baked dessert bars and more options. If you can think of a sweet treat to hit the spot - this shop has it and a wonderful homemade version of it.

I ordered some chocolate covered Strawberrys, pretzels, and macaroons and everything was absolutely delicious.

The worker Matthew was helpful and I got to meet the owner Anne, who made some solid recommendations and despite it being late, they both helped me with my purchase with a smile.

I will definitely be back!

Zach E.

Yummy ice cream and a friendly staff! We all got different flavors / topping combos but have to say the mint chip was the best.

James M.

The cake bombs tasted like it was a week old.
Everything i had was stale and hard.
Sorry but not returning again.

Dan J.

My wife ordered 25 cookies for $30 for my son's birthday. They must have been confused when she asked for 25 butter or sugar cookies with a birthday theme. And she informed them of a students peanut allergies. And they delivered peanut butter ROCKS. One kid couldn't eat and some of the kids wouldn't eat them. Kids in a classroom setting don't have a glass of milk to dip into.

Edward S.

Amazing Sweet Shop. Perfect candy store for kids and adults! Candy pastries!! Great Coffee. The chocolate chip tacos are amazing as are the Adult Milkshakes! Love family owned businesses like this!